| Riley Peterson | 2023 | UW Milwaukee |
| Charlie McChesney | 2022 | UW Oshkosh |
| Nick West | 2022 | Madison College |
| Mason Fink | 2022 | UW Stevens Point |
| EJ Jaschinski | 2022 | Carroll University |
| Logan Neuroth | 2022 | UW Stout |
| Jacob Kisting | 2021 | Bradley University |
| Colby Davis | 2021 | Edgewood College |
| James Rae | 2021 | UW-Lacrosse |
| Andres Kleinsek | 2021 | Bryant & Stratton College
|
| Joe Ducharme | 2020 | Bryant & Stratton College |
| Parker Jones | 2020 | Central College |
| Sam Pederson | 2019 | McHenry County Junior College |
| Reagan Klawiter | 2019 | Illinois State University |
| Tristan Largent | 2018 | Concordia University |
| Stephen Lund | 2018 | Gonzaga University |
| Jacob Slonim | 2017 | McHenry County Junior College |
| Keaton Knueppel | 2016 | Gonzaga University |
| Ben Rortvedt | 2016 | Minnesota Twins (2nd round, 56th overall) |
| John Moynihan | 2014 | McHenry County Junior College, UW Milwaukee |
| Luke Yapp | 2012 | Northern Illinois University |
| David Lund | 2012 | Northern Iowa Community College, UW—Oshkosh |
| Ben Jennings | 2011 | Edgewood College |
| Ben Neumann | 2011 | Northern Illinois University |
| Josh Hainzinger | 2011 | Kankakee Community College |
| Cole Kroncke | 2010 | Madison College, UW—Parkside |
| Trevor Burmeister | 2009 | Madison College, UW—LaCrosse |
| Justin Scanlon | 2008 | Madison College, Michigan State University |
| Matthew Giesfeldt | 2002 | Edgewood College |
| David Burgenske | 2001 | Edgewood College |
| Eli Leonard | 1999 | Iowa Western Community College, Madison College |
| Pat Kelter | 1998 | Edgewood College |
| Andrew Felder | 1997 | Lakeland College |
| | |
About VAHS Wildcats Baseball